When you win an Academy Award for Best Directing, you can do pretty much anything you want regarding creative control as a director. Guillermo del Toro (Pan’s Labyrinth, Crimson Peak) has elevated himself to the point where his constraints have been lifted. Following his Best Director Academy Award (The Shape of Water), del Toro could have picked whatever project he wanted to do next, and he would have had swarms of A-list actors lined up to work with him. Ironically, with Nightmare Alley, he went about as mainstream as he’s ever gone before. This is not to say this 2021 Best Picture nominee isn’t without its share of the bizarre.