I’m not going to lie. The only reason I watched Michael Gracey’s The Greatest Showman was that it was the topic of one of the sermons at my church. Each year, we have a summer movie series (In 2018, the movies were Forrest Gump, Good Will Hunting, The Princess Bride, and The Shawshank Redemption. I had seen all four, of course, and watched all of them again before that week’s service to refamiliarize myself with each of these fantastic films. Then, on Labor Day weekend, we have our Family Weekend, where the church’s children sit with their caregivers rather than go to the classes they usually attend. We show a truncated movie version, and this year, it was The Greatest Showman. So, I added it to my Netflix queue. It arrived two days before my church service, and I watched it the night before. I’m usually not a fan of musicals, but I enjoyed The Greatest Showman and would consider watching it again one day.
The Greatest Showman fared much better with audiences (87%) than critics (56%). I could see that. I guess. There are a couple of genres that I struggle with reviewing. They include animated movies (which I don’t review), documentaries (that I don’t review), and musicals (which I sometimes attempt to review ~ La La Land, Les Miserables). At least, like La La Land, The Greatest Showman was a film I could follow. I still am uncertain what happened in Les Miserables, though I liked some of the singing. And if you are going to film a musical, you’ve just got to do what you’ve got to do to get Hugh Jackman (Logan, Prisoners). Of course, there are exceptions to the rule, but moviegoers would give this movie a chance (even if it was horrible) as long as Jackman was in it. Jackman can sing, dance, and bring depth to characters that many other actors cannot. The Greatest Showman is a musical retelling of Phineas Taylor “P.T.” Barnum (Jackman), the visionary behind the legendary Barnum & Bailey circus. While inspired by actual events, the film version is just that. While P.T. Barnum founded the most famous circus in the industry’s history, this story was more of his dream how he wished it might have gone down than how it went down. Nonetheless, the movie never claims to be based on a true story, and if you read the fact versus fiction story from the link above, you’ll agree that the movie is a much more exciting telling of the formation of the circus.
Like many movies, The Greatest Showman tries to do many little things well rather than just focusing on one thing great. Set in the mid-1800s, the film portrays Barnum as a fighter for people of abnormalities and disabilities and accepting things like multiracial relationships. In contrast, there was a multiracial relationship in this movie, portrayed between Barnum’s protege Phillip (Zac Efron – High School Musical, Neighbors) and trapeze artist Anne (Zendaya-Dune, Challengers) and one that was accepted by those in the circus (including Barnum) but not by many others (including Phillip’s parents), this part of the story was fictional. Phillip and Anne’s characters were both entirely fictional. In terms of being a champion of those with physical disfigurements, this may be true, but he also clearly exploited them for profitmaking purposes. The film didn’t portray Barnum as all good, though it did spend the majority of time showing all the great things he did and downplaying some of the not-so-great stuff. Like everyone, shocker, he wasn’t a perfect person. But I’m getting way ahead of myself here.
After an opening number in the present, we meet Barnum as a boy. He is the son of a tailor father, and one of his clients is Mr. Hallet (Fredric Lehne – Zero Dark Thirty, Men in Black). Hallet has a daughter named Charity, who is P.T.’s age. The two form an instant friendship that sustains them while she is sent away to finish school. They send letters back and forth to each other and, fast-forward maybe 20 years? Thirty years later, P.T. returns to the same house of Mr. Hallet to take Charity (now played by Michelle Williams – Blue Valentine, Take This Waltz) away to marry her.
Charity gives up living a life of financial stability (the Hallets are very well off) for a lifetime of love with P.T. Is everything perfect? Of course not. But this is a PG movie. Williams, my favorite actress for the past decade, doesn’t bring out the same intensity in this role as in her heavier dramas. I certainly don’t think she was miscast. She was his rock for this movie. I just would have liked to have seen her with a bigger role and seen her sing more than she was allowed to. She needed to be used more. If you get Michelle Williams in your film, keep her in as many scenes as possible. But their love story was believable, and you could tell she respected a man who followed his dreams, even when his tactics might have been a little different than yours.
After P.T. is laid off from his job, he cons his local bank to give him a $10,000 loan and opens up a museum in downtown New York with all kinds of oddities as he believes people are fascinated by this. But how is this different from many other museums in the world’s greatest city? It’s not really. People reject what the museum stands for, and it fails to attract business. So, P.T. goes a step further and searches the town for individuals with deformities, other oddities, or freaks. He finds a bearded woman named Lettie, an obese man called the Lord of Leeds, who P.T. says weighs 750 pounds even though it was “only” 500, a hair-covered man named Dog Boy, an 8-foot tall man, and conjoined twins. Rather than infusing this new small group as something to look at in a museum, his inspiration is to name his new show “P.T. Barnum’s Circus” and fill it with various acts. And did he profit by putting these people on public display for exploitation? Yes, but he certainly wouldn’t have phrased it in those terms.
When you break it down, The Greatest Showman is a movie you’ve seen a hundred times. It’s a rags-to-riches story that turns into a man becoming obsessed with fame and wanting more before a humbling experience changes him. The movie adds an element between P.T. and Swedish opera singer Jenny Lind (Rebecca Ferguson – Mission Impossible: Fallout, Mission Impossible: Rogue Nation) that didn’t exist. While Jenny was a real person and was a big part of bringing money to the gate, there were many fictional elements about her, including a component that hints at unwarranted infidelity. P.T. might have been many things (good and bad), but by all accounts, he was a faithful and loving husband and father.
The song and dance are always bizarre for me when watching a film. Do you have these characters engaged in some meaningful conversation to see them continue their story by singing? Since 99.9% of the movies I watch don’t have this transition, it feels slightly off when I see it. That’s not to say that the singing wasn’t good because it was. Some of the songs were catchy, and I could understand the purpose of each song for the rest of the movie. There were plenty of actors who were able to showcase their singing ability. And I did appreciate that it wasn’t song after song (see Les Miserables). Instead, there was a dialogue involved in connecting these numbers.
The Greatest Showman was decent and should definitely be seen by fans of musicals. It would also be a pretty good musical to introduce children to. But like all movies in which she stars, please #MoreMichelleWilliams.
Plot 9/10
Character Development 9/10
Character Chemistry 8.5/10
Acting 9/10
Screenplay 8.5/10
Directing 8/10
Cinematography 9/10
Sound 10/10
Hook and Reel 8/10
Universal Relevance 8/10
87%
B
Movies You Might Like If You Liked This Movie
- La La Land
- Chicago
- Nightmare Alley
- Mamma Mia!
- Moulin Rouge!