Continuing the two themes of actors who I once didn’t really like but who, in recent films, has begun to win me over (Miles Teller) as well as films about characters suffering from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) after serving in wars in the Middle East (Thank You For Your Service) comes the critically panned Man Down, a movie that I don’t ever recall being in the theatre and didn’t know existed until a good six months after it was released. Earning a score of just 17% on Rotten Tomatoes, director Dito Montiel (A Guide to Recognizing Your Saints, Fighting) delivers an emotionally disturbing uneven film about a character traumatized by a specific incident that happened on his single tour. Man Down stars Shia LaBeouf (Lawless, American Honey) in what might be his finest performance to date. He stars as United States Marine Gabriel Drummer, who, after a raid and clearing of a house gone wrong in a village in Afghanistan, tells his story to Captain Peyton (Gary Oldman – Darkest Hour, The Dark Knight Rises), a military superior. The critics said that this movie exploits PTSD compared to a more subtle movie like Thank You For Your Service (which also has the advantage of being based on a true story, something that Man Down lacks). While I can see that, especially in the film’s final act, I disagree as a whole. War is hell. It’s one of those things that we don’t have to experience firsthand to believe. But it is something we need to experience firsthand or be close to someone who experienced it firsthand to understand truly. When we can’t, we sometimes turn to books, television, or movies hoping that they will portray a true picture for us. I think that’s what Montiel did here, even if a vast majority of his critics disagreed.
Continue reading Man Down (2016) →