Congratulations to all those associated with what will be the biggest surprise moneymaking movie of 2016. Jaume Collet-Serra’s (Non-Stop, Run All Night) The Shallows will have used a highly successful marketing campaign (which included showing its terrifying trailers during sporting events and popular primetime television shows) along with positive scores from the critics (75% fresh on Rotten Tomatoes) on its way to making, my guess, more than $300 million worldwide by the time everything is said and done. This will make The Shallows the biggest non-superhero, non-G-rated movie to be released in the first half of 2016. Of course, it’s exactly everything you would expect it to be, and that will be perfectly fine for most of its audience. If you want an escape from reality fare, this could be the movie for you. This could be the movie if you want to take your thinking cap off for an hour and a half. If you want a movie that builds upon every scene in its quest to terrify you, this could be the movie for you. Even if you want a film with beautiful cinematography, this could be the movie for you. But if you are looking for something the slightest bit believable or care about the quality of acting in your lead or sub-characters, The Shallows is not your movie.
The Shallows was the ultimate no-risk/high-reward film. I expected it to be bad. Yet, based on the trailers and the reviews, I at least knew it would be entertaining. And it was. It was quite entertaining. But as a friend of mine said, you can’t remake Jaws. And you certainly can’t. The very first shark movie will go down as forever the best shark movie. There have been other good shark movies. I enjoyed Deep Blue Sea, The Reef, and Red Water. I also really enjoyed Open Water, though I know others were irritated by this movie (much like I was by Open Water 2). However, none of these movies came close to replicating the terror and suspense associated with the 1975 classic. The Shallows was better than most other shark movies, but it was still not good. The shark looked incredibly unrealistic and, worse, acted in wildly inconsistent ways with shark behaviors. And I’m not sure about the storyline itself. A person stranded on a rock in a lagoon on a remote island while being circled by a shark doesn’t sound like it has the weight to front as a major motion picture.
The premise surrounds Nancy (Lively) visiting a beach where her recently deceased mom surfed when she was younger. Nancy wants to honor her mother’s memory by surfing the same waves while also trying to deal with her mother’s death. The beach (which has no official name) is located in Tijuana, Mexico, and is referred to as the beach of the pregnant woman because the islands off in the distance look like a pregnant woman lying on her back. Nancy is from Galveston, TX, where her father and younger sister live. We meet these characters once when Nancy video chats with both of them when she first arrives at the beach. In three minutes, we learn that her much younger sister looks up to her as her hero and that her father disapproves of her recent dropping out of medical school because of what happened to her mom.
From this, we learn a few things. First, her family loves her. She is willing to fight for her sister, her dad, and the memory of her deceased mother. Secondly, she is searching for her soul. Third, she has medical training. All of these are important, especially the medical training part. In one of the film’s first scenes, we learn from the extended jeep ride that the beach she travels to is highly secluded. It’s literally in the middle of nowhere, and the only way she can get there is through the navigation of a local who knows the terrain. Finally, we learn that she has a best friend who has accompanied her on her trip to Tijuana, but her friend had too much to drink the night before and could not make the surfing excursion. Nancy does have her cell phone, and there is plenty of service in the area, so she’ll be safe, right? She also seems to have enough food and other survival supplies where a day (or even two days) away from civilization won’t be an issue. While the beach is entirely secluded when she arrives, she does find two local surfers out in the lagoon, and, lucky for her, one of them speaks English because her Spanish isn’t excellent. It’s even worse without her phone’s translation app, which is in her bag on the beach while she is out on her surfboard. Thank God one speaks English; otherwise, the interactions could have been very embarrassing.
Blake Lively is no Tom Hanks. And The Shallows isn’t Cast Away, and Lively is asked to command the screen by herself for longer than Hanks was when he was nominated for his third consecutive Best Actor nomination. And the bird with the clipped wing that she encounters on her rock, while cute, is no Wilson. Everything felt forced throughout this movie, and I could never believe that this could happen, at least from the second of her initial shark bite going forward. The props are conveniently placed throughout the film, and Lively’s Nancy can hold it together a little too easily. Certainly, we can imagine what it would be like to have to stitch yourself, and while Nancy’s screams convey that agony, she gets over it pretty darn quickly. While others would be sent into outright shock and downright despair, Nancy uses her survival skills (where these were developed, I’ll never know) to figure out a plan to save herself.
In recent years, there has been a tendency (going back to the mid-’90s) for the heroes not always to come out clean. Does this movie follow this newer philosophy, or does it follow the template of the main character surviving until the end? I won’t ruin it for you other than saying I didn’t know until the end. I mean, maybe I did, but I wasn’t convinced. So Collet-Serra had that going for him. Is the ending satisfactory? I wouldn’t go that far, but it held my interest until the end.
There will be those who like this movie much more than I did. However, the young generation who missed seeing Jaws or their shark movie will dig it. This movie deserves a slightly better rating than just 60.5%, but I couldn’t get past the awful acting, the screenplay (mainly the dialogue), and the shark itself.
Plot 4/10 (been there, done that with stories that are far more believable and with characters we care far more deeply for)
Character Development 5/10
Character Chemistry 4/10
Acting 4/10 (Blake Lively is not quite ready to carry a movie alone. To her defense, she was given a pretty awful script with some of the worst dialogue I’ve seen in years; as awful as she was, the supporting actors in this film made Lively look like Meryl Streep)
Screenplay 4/10 (OMG…)
Directing 7/10 (Collet-Serra is much closer to Robert Zemeckis than Lively is a Tom Hanks)
Cinematography 9.5/10 (beautiful)
Sound 8/10 (above average for sure)
Hook and Reel 8/10 (though I wasn’t a huge fan, it did reel me in, and I was entertained throughout)
Universal Relevance 7/10 (While shark attacks are undoubtedly real, I don’t know what kind of shark hunts its prey for 12+ hours when the shark doesn’t even know if its prey is there; also, who goes to a secluded beach in a foreign country alone?)
60.5%
D+
Movies You Might Like If You Liked This Movie